Study hopes to encourage use of new technology to reduce errors in DNA testing

August 14, 2020

By Jan Jarvis 

Dr. Jianye Ge

Today’s DNA testing is highly accurate, but errors still occur due to the limited genetic information accessible with current technologies. These errors can have serious impact on people’s lives. 

New technology has been shown to reduce the chances of false associations and should be more widely used, said Jianye Ge, PhD., Associate Professor and Associate Director of the Center for Human Identification. In a study titled “How Many Familial Relationship Testing Results Could Be Wrong?” Dr. Ge reviewed worldwide practices to assess the potential of errors. Co-author of the study is Dr. Bruce Budowle, Director and Professor for the Center for Human Identification. 

 “Millions of cases have been tested globally,” Dr. Ge said. “Of those, tens of thousands of cases could have been falsely interpreted.”  

The paper published in PLOS Genetics points out that existing problems of paternity testing have occurred over many years. Those errors are namely unrelated individuals being falsely concluded as biological relatives and biological relatives being falsely concluded as not related, such as a biological father concluded as unrelated to a child in paternity testing cases.  

“We used a realistic model to estimate that tens of thousands of cases could be wrongly interpreted over the past two decades,” Dr. Ge said. “The problem is the current technology has limitations and thus improvements are needed.” 

Testing via short tandem repeat or STR-based technology has long been the gold standard of familial relationship testing, such as civil and criminal paternity tests, missing persons identification, and kinship verification with international migration. It is the same tool used in forensics worldwide to distinguish who may or may not have been the donor of biological evidence found at the crime scenes. 

Since the STR markers for DNA typing was introduced in the late 1990s, there has not been dramatic improvements in testing. 

“In the beginning, only a few STRs were used,” Dr. Ge said. “That improved to 20 to 23, which is what is used now.” 

“The chance of a mistake with that technology is small, but because of the sheer magnitude of testing – millions of cases – errors are not uncommon.” he said. 

Advances in technology over the last decade allow typing of hundreds of thousands or millions of single nucleotide polymorphisms, or SNPs. 

 “With the high density SNP-based technology, the chance of making a mistake is substantially less likely,” Dr. Ge said.  

Although UNTHSC stopped providing civil paternity testing services years ago, it still uses the STR technology and information in the context of missing person cases and criminal paternity cases. Nationwide the center does about 1,000 missing persons cases a year. 

“We do lots of relationship testing to determine if a missing person belongs to a family,” Dr. Ge said. “We need to continue to reduce the chance of making a false conclusion.” 

The purpose of the study was to encourage the community to move forward to this new generation of testing“We need to move forward so that mistakes in kinship relationship testing are less of a possibility,” he said.

John Licciardone Hsc Fort Worth Fc
eHealth interventions could help African-American patients in battle with chronic pain

By Steven Bartolotta The PRECISION Pain Research Registry at the University of North Texas Health Science Center in Fort Worth has identified important racial disparities in pain management that became more evident during the COVID-19 pandemic. Its study recently published in the special COVID...Read more

Jun 14, 2021

Diana Cervantes. Assistant Professor Biostatistics & Epidemiology
Dr. Diana Cervantes named among Fort Worth’s ‘most influential’ for public health service during the pandemic

By Sally Crocker Dr. Diana Cervantes has spent the last year keeping people informed and updated on all things coronavirus, and now she’s being recognized as one of Fort Worth Inc.’s “400 Most Influential People” for helping protect the community’s health during the pandemic. Dr....Read more

Jun 8, 2021

Opal Lee photo by Rodger Mallison/Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Celebrating Juneteenth

By Diane Smith-Pinckney On June 19 1865, Major General Gordan Granger marched into Galveston with a critical message: “The people of Texas are informed that, in accordance with a Proclamation from the Executive of the United States, all slaves are free.”  This was the opening se...Read more

Jun 8, 2021

Dr. Scott Walters
The realities of ‘breaking bad’ and how one HSC researcher is attacking the opioid crisis

By Sally Crocker He didn’t know it at the time, but when Dr. Scott Walters was growing up in San Diego in the mid 1980s, a next-door neighbor was concealing a homemade meth lab just across the fence and mere steps away from his bedroom window. For quite some time, concerned parents in his fa...Read more

Jun 8, 2021